The Ultimate Guide To The Best Pizza In Brooklyn

Brooklyn, New York, is a pizza lover's paradise. With its rich culinary history and an ever-evolving food scene, Brooklyn is home to some of the most iconic pizzerias in the world. From classic tomato pies baked in coal-fired ovens to innovative slices topped with unique ingredients, the borough offers endless options to satisfy your pizza cravings. Whether you're a local or a visitor, uncovering the best pizza in Brooklyn is an adventure worth savoring.

In a city where every corner seems to boast a pizza joint, finding the best pizza in Brooklyn can feel overwhelming. Each neighborhood has its own beloved spots with loyal followings, and the competition is fierce. But don't worry — we've combed through the borough to bring you a curated list of must-try pizzerias. Whether you're seeking a thin and crispy crust, gooey mozzarella, or a robust tomato sauce, Brooklyn's pizza scene has something for everyone.

So, what makes Brooklyn pizza so special? It's more than just the ingredients; it’s about the passion and craftsmanship behind each slice. Many of these pizzerias have been family-run for generations, perfecting recipes that have stood the test of time. In this guide, we’ll explore the top spots for the best pizza in Brooklyn, answer your burning questions, and help you plan your next pizza outing. Let’s dive in!

Table of Contents

• What Makes Brooklyn Pizza Unique?
• Where Can You Find the Best Pizza in Brooklyn?
• Top 10 Pizzerias in Brooklyn You Must Try
• How to Choose the Right Pizza Spot?
• What Are the Different Types of Pizzas in Brooklyn?
• Is Brooklyn Pizza Really Better Than Manhattan?
• Classic vs. Modern Pizzerias in Brooklyn
• How to Make the Most of Your Pizza Tour?
• Family-Friendly Pizzerias in Brooklyn
• Are There Vegan Options for Pizza Lovers?
• A Slice of History: The Evolution of Brooklyn Pizza
• What Are the Top Pizza Toppings in Brooklyn?
• How to Pair Your Pizza with Drinks?
• Budget-Friendly Pizza Spots in Brooklyn
• What Makes a Perfect Brooklyn Pizza?

What Makes Brooklyn Pizza Unique?

Brooklyn pizza stands out because of its attention to quality and tradition. Many pizzerias use locally-sourced ingredients and traditional cooking methods, such as coal-fired or wood-fired ovens, to achieve a signature flavor and texture. The crust, often thin yet chewy, is a hallmark of Brooklyn-style pizza, and the toppings range from classic mozzarella and pepperoni to gourmet options like truffle oil and prosciutto.

The borough’s diverse population also plays a role in shaping its pizza scene. You’ll find influences from Italian-American traditions, as well as modern twists inspired by Brooklyn’s melting pot of cultures. This combination of old-school techniques and innovative ideas makes Brooklyn pizza truly one of a kind.

Where Can You Find the Best Pizza in Brooklyn?

If you're wondering where to start your pizza journey, there are a few neighborhoods that stand out as must-visits. Williamsburg, Dumbo, and Park Slope are known for their trendy eateries and artisanal pizza spots. Meanwhile, areas like Bensonhurst and Bay Ridge boast long-standing pizzerias with deep roots in the community.

Some of the most iconic names include Di Fara Pizza in Midwood, Lucali in Carroll Gardens, and Grimaldi's near the Brooklyn Bridge. Each of these establishments has earned a reputation for exceptional pizza, drawing locals and tourists alike. But don’t stop there — Brooklyn is brimming with hidden gems waiting to be discovered.

Top 10 Pizzerias in Brooklyn You Must Try

1. Di Fara Pizza – Known for its legendary pies crafted by Domenico DeMarco.
2. Lucali – Famous for its BYOB policy and hand-rolled dough.
3. Grimaldi's – A coal-fired institution near the Brooklyn Bridge.
4. Juliana's – A modern take on classic pizza by the original Grimaldi's owner.
5. Roberta's – A hip spot in Bushwick offering creative toppings.
6. L&B Spumoni Gardens – Home to the iconic square Sicilian slice.
7. Paulie Gee’s – Renowned for its innovative Neapolitan-style pies.
8. Totonno's – One of the oldest pizzerias in Coney Island.
9. Emily – Known for its distinctive Detroit-style pies.
10. Joe’s Pizza – A classic slice shop with a cult following.

How to Choose the Right Pizza Spot?

Choosing the best pizza in Brooklyn depends on your preferences. Are you a fan of thin crust, or do you love a thick Sicilian slice? Do you prefer traditional toppings, or are you looking for something adventurous? Consider these factors when picking a spot:

• Crust Style: Thin, thick, or somewhere in between?
• Toppings: Classic or creative?
• Ambience: Casual takeout joint or sit-down restaurant?
• Price: Budget-friendly or fine dining?

With so many options, it’s worth trying a few different places to find your personal favorite.

What Are the Different Types of Pizzas in Brooklyn?

Brooklyn offers a variety of pizza styles to suit every taste. Some of the most popular types include:

• Neapolitan: Soft, chewy crust with simple, high-quality ingredients.
• New York-Style: Thin and foldable slices, perfect for eating on the go.
• Sicilian: Thick, square slices with a crispy bottom.
• Artisanal: Gourmet pies with unique toppings and innovative flavors.

Is Brooklyn Pizza Really Better Than Manhattan?

The debate between Brooklyn and Manhattan pizza is never-ending. While Manhattan boasts its fair share of legendary pizzerias, many argue that Brooklyn holds the edge due to its diverse options and commitment to tradition. The borough’s pizzerias often feel more authentic and less commercialized, making it a favorite among true pizza enthusiasts.

Classic vs. Modern Pizzerias in Brooklyn

Brooklyn’s pizza scene is a blend of old and new. Classic pizzerias like Totonno’s and L&B Spumoni Gardens have been serving the community for decades, sticking to time-honored recipes. On the other hand, modern spots like Roberta’s and Paulie Gee’s are pushing the boundaries with creative toppings and techniques. Both styles have their merits, so why not explore both?

How to Make the Most of Your Pizza Tour?

Planning a pizza tour in Brooklyn? Here are some tips to maximize your experience:

• Start Early: Beat the crowds by visiting popular spots during off-peak hours.
• Share Slices: Order a few slices to share so you can try more places.
• Explore Neighborhoods: Each area offers its own unique pizza gems.
• Bring Cash: Some old-school pizzerias are cash-only.

Family-Friendly Pizzerias in Brooklyn

Looking for a spot to enjoy pizza with the whole family? Try these family-friendly pizzerias:

• L&B Spumoni Gardens: Spacious and welcoming for kids.
• Grimaldi's: A classic spot with a lively atmosphere.
• Emmy Squared: Offers something for everyone, including kids’ menus.

Are There Vegan Options for Pizza Lovers?

Yes, Brooklyn caters to vegan pizza lovers with several great options. Pizzerias like Paulie Gee’s and Screamer’s Pizzeria offer plant-based pies that don’t compromise on flavor. From cashew cheese to veggie-packed toppings, vegan diners have plenty to choose from.

A Slice of History: The Evolution of Brooklyn Pizza

The story of Brooklyn pizza dates back to the early 20th century, when Italian immigrants brought their culinary traditions to New York. Over the years, these recipes evolved to reflect the tastes of the local community. Today, Brooklyn pizza is a symbol of the borough’s rich cultural heritage and a testament to its ever-changing food scene.

What Are the Top Pizza Toppings in Brooklyn?

While classic toppings like pepperoni and mushrooms remain popular, Brooklyn pizzerias are known for their creative combinations. Some unique toppings to try include:

• Hot honey
• Truffle oil
• Prosciutto and arugula
• Clams
• Spicy soppressata

How to Pair Your Pizza with Drinks?

The right drink can elevate your pizza experience. Consider pairing your slice with:

• Beer: A crisp lager or hoppy IPA complements pizza perfectly.
• Wine: Red wines like Chianti or Barbera pair well with tomato-based pies.
• Soda: A classic choice for a casual pizza night.

Budget-Friendly Pizza Spots in Brooklyn

On a budget? Don’t worry — you can still enjoy some of the best pizza in Brooklyn without breaking the bank. Joe’s Pizza and Artichoke Basille’s Pizza are great options for high-quality, affordable slices.

What Makes a Perfect Brooklyn Pizza?

A perfect Brooklyn pizza is all about balance. The crust should be thin but sturdy enough to hold the toppings. The sauce should be tangy and flavorful, complemented by fresh, high-quality cheese. And finally, the toppings should enhance, not overpower, the overall experience. When done right, every bite is a harmonious blend of textures and flavors.